Creepy Sal x Reader fanfiction part 4

Y'all Halloween is almost here. I got my costume and I look 1000× more hot when I wear it than when I wear my normal clothes. Also, there's this girl and guy at my school and I have a crush on both of them. Anyways, enjoy. Also, had therapy today. Slay 💅💅✨✨

Edit: uh oh. Creepo alert up ahead heehee.

I invited Ash over to my apartment because we're making costumes for halloween. She taught me how to use the sewing machine as she's also in a sewing class (just pretend. I've been making shit up since the start of this fanfic) She's going as a ghost, and I'm going as a witch. Not much but we wanted to go as the classics for this year. 

My boyfriend was going as Jason, and Larry was going as ghost face. (I don't own these characters lol) 

Chug and Maple were going as Gomez and Morticia Addams. Relationship goals. And Todd isn't going to be spending this Halloween with us. He'd rather not. I think he was gonna spend it with this guy he was currently talking to that he seems to be taking a liking to. If I remember, I think his name was Neil? Anyways, back to me and Ash, my boyfriend waltzed into my apartment with a bag in his hand. 

 "How's my baby boy/girl/doll doing?" He said in a low voice as he walked in. 

 " Sally faaaaaaccce, you don't gotta call me that, you know? " 

He just chuckled and sat on the couch while me and Ash were assessing stuff on the coffee table. I gotta say, my costume looking bomb as fuck so far if I do say so myself. "Hey Sally, can you grab my water bottle, please? It's on my desk in my room." I asked politely because mama ain't raising no fool. " Oh yeah, that's fine. " You know, I think Sally face is improving. He's respecting my boundaries a little bit more and hasn't given me any more hickeys without my consent since last time. I think he's making remarkable improvement. Right?

WRONG! This is going to be out of your POV so get ready for garbage narration presented by my mom's middle child, me

On the outisde, Sal was giving off a good impression to Y/n's mother and y/n themself to be known as the best boyfriend. However on the inside, he was aching to touch that sweet flesh of theirs and to hear them moan his name. To cause such sweet friction with them. And submit to his every word. He was hungry for them. Hungry for love.

As he made his way to Y/n's room to grab their water bottle, he found their undergarments on the other side of the room. He knew it would be a sick move to grab it... But he didn't care. He snatched that faster than the flash. He had to get that water bottle for Y/n, but at the same time, he wanted to stay in their room. Because walking in there felt like stepping in front of the gates of heaven. 

He couldn't stay their for long. So he came up with a plan after that small get together on halloween. He was gonna invite Y/n to his house because his dad wouldn't be home, and maybe have sex with them in his bedroom. It sounded creepy but that's the title of this story so, you readers kinda knew what you were getting yourselves into I mean... After grabbing the water bottle, he quickly stuffed the undergarments in his pocket and walked out. Closing the door behind him. He made his way to the couch giving the water bottle to his partner

 "Thanks, babe." They said.

 " No problem" he said while grinning devilishly underneath his expressionless mask. What a bastard /j 

Alrighty, end of POV. Get back to your story Y/n

I finished with my costume already. Finally. And oh my gods, it looked super cute. I worked on this for like almost a month. Thanks to Ash, I finished it. Kudos to her. And kudos to mah babe for giving my some tasty water. 

 "Y/n, that looks so good! I'm proud of you!" Ash spoke before leaning over and hugging me. She felt warm. I looked over and I see that my boyfriend is just sitting there. And that's when I notice that bag sitting right next to him. 

"Hey Sally face, what's in the bag? "

 "I'll show you later. After you and Ash finish." 

 I look back at Ash and I see that she's locking eyes with Sal. Her expression is a mixture of annoyed and angry. Did some tea happen between them or something? Because they looked like they finna pounce at each other's throats. 

 "I gotta go. It's passed my curfew." She said as she was putting all her equipment back into her bag. 

 " But it's the weekend " I said to her

 "I'll see you at school Y/n. Goodbye now."

 " Uh, goodbye. " 

I tried to say it as sweet as I could before she closed the door. I'm lucky, because my mom isn't around that often. She usually pops in from time to time, but that's to make sure I'm doing okay or if it's to stay for the night. But that aside I still focus on the bag my boyfriend brought in. 

 "Soooooo, what's in the bag?" 

"O-oh, follow me" sound suspicious, but we all do sometimes. He takes me into my room and plops me onto my bed. Where he get the bag out and pulls these black and orange striped thigh highs out of the bag. Oh my gods, I was ecstatic. A huge smile appeared on my face as I began to bounce up and down repeatedly in my bed like a little kid. I probably looked pathetic. "Wow, you got that excited just by me presenting you with socks?" Sal asked as I nodded my head so many times as an answer. 

He chuckled and set the thigh highs on my lap to grab something else out of my bag. An orange Halloween themed choker with black spikes. Holy shit, give this man best boyfriend award like literally right now. I felt like I was going to fucking cry tears of happiness. I squealed and got up to hug him. He reciprocated and unclipped his mask to but it on my night stand. With this, he turned to me and kissed my lips, I never felt any kiss from him feel this passionate. 

 "You're the best boyfriend ever." I said while smiling up to him

 " You're the best boyfriend/girlfriend/partner ever" he said as he went in for another kiss. I'm starting to fall more and more in love with him everyday. Can't wait for the Halloween get together.

Y'all already know what their getting themself into after that Halloween get together with friends. Anyways, I think I might tell my crushes how I feel about both of them cause like,  aaahhh!!! My gay ass fell for both of them (I'm nonbinary btw) anyways, drink water kings/queens/majesty 

1187 words