Chapter 27: Vanilla Treat*

I wake up Monday morning to Spencer's alarm. He's wrapped around my body, limbs entangled with limbs. My limbs are still pissed at his limbs though, but I know acting out will get me nowhere. Spencer groans and gets up as I roll over and stretch "what time is it, Spence?" He shushes me and says "it's 6:30. I know you have a late day today, so go back to sleep, baby." I nod and quickly roll over and pretend to go back to sleep. I hear Spencer dress, he doesn't shower after we had quite a long bath last night. After he's ready he comes around to my side of the bed and leans down and kisses me on the forehead and says "I love you, Annie, I'm going to work. Have a good day." I hum and say "you, too, Spence." He chuckles as he leaves the room and heads out the door. He should honestly eat breakfast. That's probably why he's a literal pool noodle. I get out of bed and go to get coffee. I couldn't even enjoy my late day to sleep in because my body was on fire after Spencer's punishment last night. It was enjoyable, but it would've been better if he let me finish. I wait about 30 minutes, until I know Spencer has made it to work before I call him. He answers on the second ring "hey, Annie, I just got to work everything okay?" I bite my lip and say "yeah, Spence, I just couldn't get back to sleep." He sighs and says "I'm sorry baby I shouldn't have woken you." I say "no it's okay, I didn't sleep well last night in general." He hums "so what's up why are you calling?" I hum and say "if you're around people you may want to step away." He chuckles "I already stepped away when you called. What's going on?" I bite my lip, suddenly very nervous. I finally ask "I was just um wondering if I could have um...permission?" Spencer laughs and says "I guess your punishment last night was effective, huh? Usually I would probably say no so you'd have to wait for me to take care of that, but I feel generous after last night. So the answer is yes, but you can only finish once." I nod to myself excitedly "okay, thank you!" Spencer chuckles and says "one more thing, Annie." I say "yes, Spencer?" He chuckles "leave your panties there for me for when I get home. Understand?" I nod to myself and bite my lip "yes, I understand." He chuckles "okay, have fun, princess" before he hangs up. I practically skip back to our bedroom and I decide I'm not in the mood for a slow burn. I run to the closet and get out one of Spencer's vibrators that he's used on me before. I lay down on our bed and I take the vibrator and turn it on a low setting, barely touching it to my clothed heat. I moan out in pleasure at the feeling. I turn the setting up a notch and start to move it in circles on my clit on top of my clothes. It doesn't take much before I quickly feel my climax coming on and I kick the vibrator up a notch and pick up the pace. I come hard and finally feel relief after days of nothing and one day of intense edging. I lay there for a second, breathing hard and coming down from my high. I feel much better after that. I hum as I get up to shower, now that I obviously need to after that. I leave the panties in the bathroom and send him a text telling him where he can find what he asked for when he gets home. He responds with a single text.

Spence 💜Good girl. Have a good day, see you at home tonight. Love you!

I feel myself smile and butterflies flutter at the text. Damn, I do have a praise kink, don't I? As I shower I think about ways to avoid running in to Killian. I know if I run into her I'll accidentally call her ma'am or give myself away somehow. Of all people this had to happen to me. I had to accidentally overhear one of my best friends give my boyfriend's boss head in a fancy restaurant bathroom. I kind of want to yell at her because that was the domino that caused Spencer to go from 0-100 and punish me hardcore last night. I'd be lying if I said I didn't like it. I was just afraid of what Spencer would say if he knew just how innocent I really wasn't. Sure, I'm physically inexperienced but my mind isn't. I get dressed and put on makeup and leave my hair down to air dry as I take Ryder for a walk. It's probably not a good idea because it's November in DC, but now I'm in a time crunch after adding in my fun and my shower. We just go for a quick walk around the block and I bring him back home before I leave to go to work. I get in the office around 10, still with wet hair and sit down at my desk to get my patients' charts together and organized for the day before I start my rounds. As I'm getting all of my stuff ready when Killian comes in and sits down and says "Girl I had the best sex last night." I hear a commotion and then Alison pops her head in from her office next door to mine. She says with a sly smile "did I just hear what I think I did?" I chuckle and tell her to come in and shut the door. The girls sit down in the chairs in front of my desk and Alison goes "tell me all about it!" I hold my breath and grind my teeth because I don't want to know about Hotch's sex life. Killian giggles and says "well this hookup I've been seeing on again off again took me out to dinner last night because he's been out of town and he said he missed me. We went to Maestro's in DC. When we got home he made me finish 4 times before I had to pull him off of me." I chuckle and say "I've had one of those nights." The girls turn to me with wide eyes Alison says "both of these guys need to talk to my husband because he is obviously not doing something right." I think to myself that maybe it's just the men of the BAU team and chuckle. Killian says "wait a damn minute I want to hear about that night you just mentioned." My face flushes and I sip my Diet Coke and don't say anything. Alison says "come on, Annie, spill. We won't judge you, you know that." I nod and say "well...um...on Spencer's birthday he was so happy with everything I had done and with his gift that he took the day off after his party and we went home together." Killian sighs with impatience "girl if that's all the dirty deets you have to give I'm going to be pissed." I chuckle and shake my head "that's not all...he uh kinda slammed me against the car in the parking garage before we left and he said he wanted to take my clothes off right there and didn't want to wait until we got home. We did get home before he did that, but he teased me the whole way there." The girls are smiling big with wide eyes like this is the juiciest gossip they've heard in their entire lives. I continue "he told me when we got home to strip to the set I had gotten him for his birthday. He also pulled out a...toy...that he got himself, or me I'm not sure who, for his birthday. He also cuffed me to the headboard with his work cuffs." Alison goes "what in the world, Annie?" At the same time Killian goes "atta girl!" I hide my face out of slight embarrassment as we all laugh. Killian says wait "how many times was it?" I raise an eyebrow "how many times did we have sex or how many times did I finish?" Alison says "both!" I chuckle "2 and 7." In unison Alison and Killian say "what?!" I chuckle and hide my face again. Alison said "wow just imagine what he's going to do for you for your birthday." I chuckle and nod my head "he is full of surprises." Killian says "who knew Dr. Daddy Long Legs actually had daddy energy?" We all laugh at the question before dispersing to actually work while at work.

•••••

I get home from work around 7 to the rare sight of Spencer at home on a Monday and not on a case. He's in the kitchen cooking dinner and I'm instantaneously relieved that I don't have to cook or figure out what to do for dinner. He turns around at the sound of the door and the sounds of Ryder's excitement and smiles at me. I smile back and walk over to him after greeting Ryder and hug him around his waist from behind. I softly say "hi" into his back as I gently squeeze him. He laughs softly "hi, why are you so quiet?" I shrug my shoulders with my arms still wrapped around him and say "I'm just tired Spence, Mondays are hard sometimes." He fully turns around and puts his arms around me and kisses me on top of my head. We hold each other in comfortable silence and he says "why don't you go change into some comfortable clothes and get in bed and I'll bring you your dinner when it's ready. I look at him suspiciously "why are you doing all this? Is there something I should know?" Spencer laughs heartily "I'm just rarely home on Mondays and you worked late tonight. I've had time to decompress after work and you haven't. Go relax and let me take care of dinner tonight, hmm?" I still look at him suspiciously and nod "I'll go put on my pajamas and spend some time with Ryder. We can eat out here I don't want to eat in bed, really." Spencer nods "okay, I'll come get you when dinner is ready, go destress." I smile and kiss him before following his directions. I go back to our bedroom and change into my warmest fleece pajama set because it's so cold outside. I curl up with Ryder and turn on a comfort show before I quickly and unintentionally doze off. I wake shortly after to the sound of Spencer trying to sneak back out the bedroom door after he found me asleep. I groan and roll over, stretching as I say "is dinner ready?" Spencer nods "if you just want to go to sleep I can put it in the fridge, though." I shake my head as I get up and put my slippers on then take Spencer's hand as I walk into the kitchen. He's made spaghetti and garlic bread and I'm so happy that he made a dinner with cheese and carbs after my tiring day. I turn to him and kiss him deeply. He chuckles "what was that for?" I smile "thank you for knowing just how to take care of me, Spence." He smiles "you are one of my favorite subjects to study." I chuckle as I sit at the island to eat with Spencer. He looks at me and asks "is it a wine night, a Diet Coke night, or water night?" I chuckle at the question "I'll take a glass of wine since you're offering and you made Italian food." Spencer nods and pours two glasses of Merlot for us to sip on with our spaghetti and garlic bread. I ask Spencer "tell me about your day, baby?" He nods "well it was mostly paperwork, but we did have to do like a review training thing in our gear. You know just protocol stuff." I look at him intrigued "wait I feel like that would be terrifying." Spencer nods as he finishes chewing his bite "it was terrifying my first year or so, but now that I've done it in real life so many times the training is easy. They do try to make it more challenging and throw in surprises. Hotch reviews our performance with us individually and we try to work on our strengths and weaknesses in individual training when we have time at Quantico." I nod and then ask "that makes sense. Speaking of Hotch, was it weird for you to talk to him today?" Spencer raises a brow "not for me, I tried not to think too much about his private life outside of the office." I hum in agreement "kind of hard for me to do that after I heard him climax in the women's bathroom." He laughs hard at that and says "I would imagine so. Did you talk to Killian today at work?" I nod "she gave me some details about her sex life." Spencer looks flabbergasted "why?" I chuckle "that's something girls talk about, Spence." He furrows his brow and stutters a bit before saying "all girls do this?" I smile and nod "yes Spence I'm sure you've overheard the BAU girls talk about this stuff at some point." He shakes his head "I try to block it out." I laugh "Spence, you do an amazing job in there, but talking to your friends about it can be very helpful. Also very entertaining. Apparently Hotch gave Killian 4 orgasms last night." Spencer let's out a yell of disgust as he covers his ears and says "I don't want to hear about that, Annie!" I chuckle "honestly, baby, I figured you had to talk to somebody about all this to be as good as you are." Spencer turns a bit pink and smiles smugly "thanks." I roll my eyes "how did you learn all of the sex stuff you know?" He mentally goes through the inventory as he sways his head back and forth gently "I do read a lot of books, knowing basic anatomy helps a lot. I did have an old friend I turned to when I was going through my breakup with Lila and it turned into a friends with benefits situation." I nod as I twirl my spaghetti around my fork "how exactly did that come about? I won't be mad or anything I'm just curious." He nods as he takes a sip of his wine "I just told her about a lot of my issues with Lila and how I was very...very um...insecure with my body and my abilities sexually. Lila wasn't supportive or encouraging. She knew I was a virgin when we started dating and she was caring and patient the first few times. I guess I just didn't advance as much as she wanted or fast as she wanted. I didn't last long in the beginning either for obvious reasons and building my stamina is what I worked on a lot with my friend." I gently rub his arm as he talks about Lila, I know it's hard for him. I nod "who was this friend? Have I met her?" He shakes his head "no, her name is Elle, she worked at the BAU when I first started but she left a long time ago. We didn't start our mutually beneficial arrangement until well after she had left. I would tell her about Lila and she offered to help. She was one of the few people I felt safe and comfortable with so I agreed." I nod as I listen intently to his words "and she's who really got you into BDSM?" He nods before saying "originally I was the submissive for her when we started. As I got more comfortable and experienced she let me try dominating her. For a while after we both would just switch back and forth depending on the other's needs." I nod "Spence, please be honest when you answer this question, but did you or do you love her?" Spencer shakes his head "I care deeply about her. She was a member of my team and we have to have deep connections and protect each other. Before Lila I did have a crush on Elle, but I knew when we were just friends with benefits it wouldn't have ever worked out. Sure, the sex with her was fun and I finally felt safe and confident in my body because I was comfortable with her, but we weren't compatible beyond sex. I never loved anyone like I love you, Annie. That's the truth." I nod "do you ever still see her?" He shakes his head "we ended our arrangement well before my exposure to anthrax. She's reached out to check in when things happen like after Haley died and after I was shot, nothing more than a text or email." I nod, trying not to let my jealousies or insecurities show. Spencer grabs my hand "Annie, I'm a profiler; I can see right through you. You can't hide your jealousy from me. If you want me to discontinue all contact with her I will." I shake my head "no, I don't want you to do that. She obviously has been there for you for a long time. You trust her. I trust you. Just...just don't make me regret it." He leans forward and kisses me "Annie, I will spend the rest of my life making sure that you know that you're the only one I want forever." I smile and nod "just remember that pain from when I kicked you in the balls a few nights ago. I can make it so much worse if you do make me regret trusting you." Spencer chuckles "I know, baby. I know." I feel better knowing more about Spencer's sexual experiences. I am happy he learned all that he learned in a safe space, I wasn't too fond of the idea I had concocted on my own of me being some kind of surrogate for Lila. Knowing the BDSM was an experiment with a friend after Lila gives me mixed emotions. I do want to tell him to not talk to her anymore, but that's not fair to him. So I'll give him a chance to be trusted. I will become an unsub, though, if he screws up. After we finish our meal I take the dishes to the sink and clean them up before loading them into the dishwasher. At the same time Spencer had been packing up the leftovers into Tupperware and handed me the dirty pots and pans. I quickly clean those and put them in the dishwasher or put them away if they don't fit and start the dishwasher. I turn to Spencer as we finish up in the kitchen and ask "want to watch some Game of Thrones before bed?" He nods "sure, just let me get ready for bed first." Soon after we curl up in bed together and start watching the show. We are in season 2 so Spencer has no idea what he's really in for at the moment. There's a lot of sex in the show and I can't tell if it makes Spencer uncomfortable or if it turns him on and he tries to hide it. We continue to watch the show and my question is answered when I feel him getting hard behind me. He tries to sit very still and hopes I don't notice it, I think. I slightly turn my head to him just a bit and say "Um Spence...?" He immediately says "uhh I'm sorry," and coughs nervously as he readjusts. I giggle and say "what are you sorry for? For being turned on by the soft porn we just watched on the tv together?" He coughs nervously again and says "I just know you're really tired so I didn't want you to feel pressured by asking or saying anything." I caress his cheek with my thumb and say "Spencer that's really thoughtful of you. If you want me to help you out before bed I would be happy to..heh..lend a hand?" He chuckles at the pun and says "no, baby, it'll go down in a little bit I'm fine." I turn around and in a sing song voice say "okay but it'll go down faster with my mouth around it." Spencer groans, just slightly and quietly, and I feel his dick twitch against my butt due to our spooning position. I drop the subject because I wouldn't want him to continually ask or pressure me into participating in adult activities so I continue to watch the show. He stays hard behind me, there are more sex scenes following the first one and I'm sure our position doesn't help either. We discuss different things in the show, Spencer knows a lot about different subjects relevant to the story that gives me new insight. I learn something new from him every day. We finish the episode and get comfortable to go to sleep. Spencer gets up to go to the bathroom and I ask him "Spencer, are you going in there to jerk off?" He turns pink and says no with a high pitch voice. He's lying. I chuckle "look if you'd rather do it yourself I get it, but I'm seriously happy to help you out." He says "no, Annie th-that's okay." I hum before asking "fine then if you can go jerk off in the bathroom in private then can I touch myself while you do that?" Spencer is speechless before trying to talk again "b-but..what..why?" I giggle "you getting worked up has gotten me worked up." He looks completely dumbfounded and asks "really?" I chuckle in response "really, now if you want to do something about it then get over here. We will probably both sleep better." He takes a couple steps closer to me "you mean it? You're not just saying that to make me feel better?" I throw my head back and laugh "Spencer if you don't believe my words then you should check between my legs to see if I'm telling the truth." Spencer quickly licks his lips without even thinking about it and slowly walks over to me. He says "you know you can stop me at any time?" I chuckle "Spencer if you don't do something I'll go crazy." He shakes his head and walks over to me pulling the blankets from my body "I've turned you into such a needy little thing haven't I?" I nod as I bite my lip and readjust against the pillows. I quickly remove my pajama top and pants as Spencer drops his pajama pants and boxers before he looks at me and says "condom?" I shake my head "no, Spence." He smiles and grabs my legs, pulling me down the bed. I giggle at his actions and he smiles softly at me before leaning down and kissing me. I look into his brown eyes and ask softly "Spence?" He hums in response as he lightly pushes a strand of hair behind my ear. I smile and ask "I love the kinky stuff, but tonight could we just be vanilla? You know, just be together?" He smiles and nods "Yeah. If you didn't want to do kinky stuff sometimes before tonight we didn't have to, you know that, right?" I smile as I bite my lip and say "I know that so I'm asking now." He chuckles "your wish is my command, princess." He lightly trails his hand down to my dripping heat and says "Jesus, Annie, you're so wet and we haven't even started." I chuckle "only for you." He smiles and nods "that's right, only for me." He gently rubs his thumb over my clit and I gasp in a breath of air as I hold on to the sheets for dear life. I look down and groan in pleasure. "Spencer, please just put it in." He chuckles "oh so no foreplay?" I groan as I shake my head "no foreplay." He smiles so softly "you ready, baby?" I bite my lip and nod as he lines up with my entrance. He slowly pushes into my heat and we both moan out in pleasure. I entangle one hand in his hair and scratch my nails down his back with the other as he slowly increases his thrusts. He leans down and captures my lips with his in a heated kiss, matching his thrusts. He says in my ear as he grabs my hand, intertwining our fingers, "God, I love you so much, Annie." I say out of breath "I love you, too, Spence, so much." He continues to thrust at a comfortable pace, not too slow or too fast, hitting all the right spots every time. I let out little moans and whimpers as I feel myself already getting close, but I hold back so it isn't over so soon. He slowly sits us up, never removing himself from me, positioning me so I straddle his lap. Before he starts moving again he asks, breathless "is this okay?" I breathe heavily and nod. He leans down slightly and kisses me deeply as he places his hands on my hips and slowly starts to move me up and down on his length as I hold on to his shoulders, returning the deep kiss. He removes one hand from my hip, thrusting his hips to make up for the lost force as he takes a hand down to my clit. Rubbing it in time with his thrusts. I pull away from the kiss as I moan in pleasure and hold on to him for dear life, aiding his thrusts slightly as I move up and down with him. I moan again in pleasure as I say breathlessly "feels so good, Spence." He hums as he leaves a trail of wet kisses along my jaw and neck before asking "are you going to be a good girl cum for me baby?" I let out an involuntary whimper as I nod and hum my answer of yes to him. He never wavers in his actions and I feel the band snap within me as I explode around him. I let out my moans of pleasure as Spencer coaxes me through my orgasm "such a good girl, I love you so much." I take his lips in mine once again and put my hands in his hair, lightly pulling as I feel him fill me with his warmth, following me over the edge. He lays me down gently, engaging in a deep kiss with me as he does so. I don't want him to leave; I don't want to feel empty without him. He starts to pull out as I hum my protest and ask for a few more minutes wrapped up with him. He chuckles and nods as he holds on to me, rolling over onto his back so I lay on top of him. He pulls the blanket over us and gently rubs my back as I draw patterns on his chest with my fingertips. After a few minutes of peaceful silence in our post coital bliss I say softly "thank you, Spence." He hums "what for, princess?" I blush at the nickname "for listening to me and giving me exactly what I asked for." He hums "Annie, if you don't enjoy the BDSM stuff we don't have to do that. It's only enjoyable for me if you're enjoying yourself." I hum "last night was fun I'm just definitely more satisfied tonight." Spencer chuckles "yes that was the point. It worked because you asked my permission this morning and tonight, too, technically." I don't say anything for a minute or so. Spencer asks "why are you being so quiet?" I respond "I don't know Spence I just find it unfair that I have to ask for permission, but I don't get to know when you touch yourself." Spencer laughs at this "do you want me to ask permission from you?" I shake my head "I know you like to be more dominant and that's not how this works. I think if I have to ask for permission you could at least tell me when you're taking care of yourself. Maybe we could start implementing phone sex when you're on cases?" I've forgotten the fact that Spencer is still inside of me and thinking about phone sex has me contract the muscles in my core out of excitement. Spencer's eyes widen as he slightly lifts his upper torso off the bed briefly before gasping in pleasure. After he's caught his breath he says "do that again, but only if you want to go for round 2." I giggle "why do you think I didn't want you to leave me in the first place." He chuckles darkly at the joke as he rolls us over, I'm laying on my back again as he hovers above me. I reach up and touch his face as I say "you can go a bit faster and harder this time around if you want." He raises an eyebrow as he smiles smugly at me "that depends on if you want to be able to walk in the morning?" I smile "I've called in for less than that before. Do your worst." He chuckles darkly again "oh you're going to regret those words, Annie." I chuckle "do you want to stay in this position or move?" His eyes flash with lust "face down, ass up." I giggle as I move into position "why do you like this position so much, Spencer?" He says "for one, the added pressure from gravity on your clit makes your orgasms more intense. For two, I like the sounds you make when I pull your hair. For three, I can spank you much better in this position. I blush and say "oh." He laughs "yeah, oh." I hum "perks of loving a genius." He had to pull out of me so we could change positions, now that we've settled he lines up behind me and asks "you ready, princess?" I hum my approval as he ever so slowly pushes into me, it's not what I expected but it has me gripping the sheets and my eyes rolling into the back of my head. He pushes all the way in and asks "you okay?" I moan and nod "mmhmm so good, Spence." He chuckles and says "buckle up." I barely have time to process what he's said before he's almost completely pulled out of me and slammed back into me. His pace is fast and hot. I'm holding on to the sheets beneath me for dear life as he continues his brutal pace and smacks my ass with the same level of force. I moan out at the feelings it sends coursing through my body. He chuckles darkly "my sweet innocent Annie, I've corrupted you haven't I?" I somehow find the strength to say "only physically." He chuckles again "is that so?" I hum my affirmation as a particularly hard thrust has me moaning his name. He pulls my back up to rest against his chest as he continues to thrust at a bruising pace. He gently pulls my hair to one shoulder, sucking and biting on the bare side of my neck, leaving me at least one hickey. He holds me around the waist with one arm, lifting me up and down as he also continues his thrusts and takes his hand to my clit rubbing it in fast figure eights. I gasp and try to catch my breath as he says in my ear "If you last longer than I do I will give you one free punishment pass. If I last longer than you do then you won't come by my hand or yours for three days" I gasp as I say "deal." He chuckles darkly and whispers in my ear "you just made a deal with the devil." I contract my muscles around him and ask "did I or did you?" He groans and pulls out of me before flipping me over on my back. He enters me swiftly again as he holds my hands together on my stomach with one of his hands as the other continues working on my clit. I'm so close to finishing but I don't want to lose that punishment pass. My legs are shaking as I try to hold back my orgasm, Spencer notices and chuckles "you're going to cum for me, aren't you, kitten?" I whimper out a denial and say "not gonna come first." I'm becoming overstimulated and try to escape his grasp and thrusts and he holds me down tighter "no, no, let me make you cum." I shake my head and say "no, Dr. Reid." I feel him twitch once at the honorific and I smile at him. I bite my lip and say "want to call a truce?" He shakes his head no before quickly pulling out of me and latching his mouth to my clit and thrusting two of his fingers into my core. I gasp and grab onto the sheets again as I say "that's not fair, Spence!" He chuckles against me, before quickly thrusting back into me hard at the last second, sending me over the edge and I lose the battle with my body as I finish. My whole body is shaking as I still slightly convulse in the aftershocks of my orgasm, frustrated that Spencer cheated. I hear him groan and release his warmth into me once again after my orgasm. He chuckles as he pulls out of me, chin and mouth glistening. I shake my head "that wasn't fair and you know it." He chuckles and says "you didn't read the fine print, Angel." I furrow my brow in confusion and anger "there was no fine print!" He laughs again "you're right I'm just kidding." I say "I vote you lose due to your cheating and I win by default." Spencer shakes his head and says "okay fine, I concede, nobody wins." I nod "I'm okay with that. That was a fun idea but we should do that when we are both prepared for it, not when you're mid thrust, Spence." He chuckles and says "noted, now let's get you cleaned up," he kisses me lightly before leaving the bed to get some stuff from the bathroom to clean me up. He looks at me with a sly grin "calling in to work tomorrow?" I smile back "we will see in the morning."